http://pro-libertate.net/20151223/283-read-we-living ( )

458-1

This book is one of the toughest books I have read in terms of personal conviction.

Do I hate this book ? No.
Do I love this book ? No .
But this book made me question the otherwise black and white convictions that I have had.

For me , as I started the book . I knew I should love Kira, my personal convictions demanded this . But was she really the hero that the novel made her to be ? Whatever she did , was it so different than what Andrei did. Both of them were driven by personal convictions whether it be personal gratification or belief in a social cause , which can also be considered as personal gratification . So , why was she made the undisputed Heroine?

For me, the undisputed hero of this novel is Andrei . His growth was tremendous and he always showed the strength of his character till the very last , where Madam Rand unnaturally decided to cut him off cause such nobel a character can never survive ; this is my only complain against Andrei Taganov.

Coming to think of it , I really liked Leo with his characteristic selfishness . He , I believe , represented "The Art of Selfishness" till the very end .
But, unfortunately I cannot say that for Kira. Personally, I cannot appreciate a lady who puts her entire hopes , aspiration, wishes etc on to a guy . She holds a mantel in her heart , an untouched mantel ; which I believe was not at all her responsibility or also was not something so exalted as the entire novel . Yes, I hoped in the end she would do something for herself but she again chose to follow her dreams , the dreams she thought Leo was capable of living. I don't understand her. I know my hatred towards her is a knee jerk reaction and I hope with time I can become un affected enough to see her as Rand made her . But till then , I despise her.

As a reader , I have no complain against the writing style. The closing chapter can be compared to a few of my favorite chapters. The heart wrenching desperation was very , very real unlike other "Individual V/s State" and "dystopic" materials I have read.

This book will not be one of my favorites , not yet but will surely be one of the books with the highest learning graph. ( )

I loved the writing in this book, and even though I didn't agree with so much of what the main characters did, I was still intrigued by them and wanted to get to know them. I found myself thinking about them when I wasn't reading, as though they were real people. Granted, I can't understand Kira's obsession with Leo, but I believe she had an inner strength despite all that. I would absolutely despise life in a socialist/communist state, and I have all the more respect and admiration now for those who fought/fight against the system. Rand's characters here may seem a bit extreme, but then again, so is blind adherence to a political system that eats its own. ( )

Publicada por primera vez en 1936, Los que vivimos es un retrato vibrante y conmovedor del impacto que tuvo la Revolución rusa en un grupo de seres humanos que no exigían más que el derecho a vivir su vida y a buscar la felicidad.

Su protagonista, Kira, alter ego de la autora, estudia ingeniería y sueña con construir puentes, pero es expulsada de la universidad por sus ideas. El hombre del que está enamorada, Leo, hijo de un héroe zarista, no encuentra trabajo debido a su pasado familiar. Desesperados por subsistir, piden ayuda a Andrei, un joven comunista que ama a Kira y está convencido de la bondad del comunismo y la revolución.

No se trata sólo de un relato político. Cuenta la historia de los hombres y las mujeres que tuvieron que luchar para sobrevivir bajo las banderas rojas y los eslóganes comunistas. Y es, además, un retrato de lo que eso supuso. ¿Qué pasó con los que osaron mostrarse desafiantes? ¿Ante quienes sucumbieron?

Después de huir de Rusia a Estados Unidos, Ayn Rand quedó perpleja por el modo en que muchos intelectuales y políticos estadounidenses observaban con complacencia el auge del comunismo. Para desmontar ante ellos el «noble ideal» del colectivismo escribió esta novela, redescubierta tras el éxito de La rebelión de Atlas.