Dorothy Simpson (1)Recensioni

I'll read more of this British Detective series.

I liked the character of Luke Thanet at the start of the book. He was a conscientious and diligent inspector of Scotland Yard and was very good at solving a somewhat baffling murder. As the book went on I began to become frustrated with his condescending attitude and just wished that he would go home, have a big cuppa tea or a shot of brandy and regroup. It was the first book so perhaps the inspector is a bit overwhelmed and will come back in book#2 as a changed man with a little more tolerance for others abilities.½

The Night She Died is the first novel in the Inspector Thanet series. A pretty housewife is found murdered in her home....a knife sticking out of her chest. She was stabbed through her coat and clothes. Her husband, supposedly returning home soon after Julie Holmes was killed, found his wife's body on the floor. As Inspector Luke Thanet begins piecing together information from Julie's last few days, he finds that this case might just be more complex than it looks. Apparently Julie was a witness to another murder 20 years before. Could it be that the killer came back after two decades to stab the only witness to a long-cold murder case? Or is it someone in Julie Holmes' present day life that killed her?

I am impressed by this book. I love a great detective story, but this one stands out from the crowd. Mostly because the Inspector is talented at his job, but not portrayed as perfect. He makes mistakes, sometimes rushes to judgement, and can be overwhelmed by his emotions at times. He's human. The story not only shows him investigating the case, but also shows how his home life supports him and offers him a haven away from it all. He loves his wife and his kids....and they try to understand when he has to be away from them. Luke Thanet is portrayed as a well-rounded, human character which gives this story depth that some detective stories just don't have.

The mystery is well-written, with plenty of suspects, intriguing plot twists and an excellent ending. It is neither too simple nor too complex to be believable. The plot seems realistic, keeping my attention throughout. Both Inspector Thanet and his new sidekick, Sergeant Mike Lineham, are likable, professional, and skilled at their jobs. They are occasionally at odds with one another, but in the end work together perfectly to solve the case.

There are 15 books in the Inspector Thanet series. The series was originally published starting back in the early 1980s, but Open Road Integrated Media is releasing new ebook versions of the novels. Before being approved to read this first ebook release by Open Road, I was unfamiliar with this series. I'm so glad I read this first book! I will definitely be reading the rest of this series!

**I voluntarily read an advance reader copy of this book from Open Road Media via NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.**

This is the first Inspector Thanet mystery I read, and unintentionally, it happens to be the first in the Thanet series. It was OK, but when I considered whether I wanted to look for more in the series or read other mysteries that I have yet to get to by authors that, for me, are more than OK, I went with the other mysteries. If I find another Thanet on a $1 cart at a used-books shop, I'll probably buy it. Actually, the best part about this book is the edition I read. It is a paperback, a tad smaller than a trade paperback, but it has a dust cover! I want to trade in the book because I won't read it again, but am tempted to keep it just because it's a cool edition of the book.

Not impressed. Three different themes were repeats from earlier books in the series.

events of 20 years earlier lead to inadvertant incest and murder

This is the first in a series of mysteries involving Inspector Luke Thanet. I'd never heard of this series until I came across it while browsing Hoopla.

It was just...ok. Thanet was an okay character. He has a nice family, a nice home life, everything was just...nice. He does have a bad back, though. So there's that. He can also be a bit gruff, but always apologizes right after.

The mystery itself was engaging enough. A young woman is found stabbed to death in her home, and when it's discovered that she was a witness to a crime as a small child, Thanet must determine if her death is related to that past event, or if someone in her present day life is responsible.

These books were first written in the 1980's--this one originally published in 1981, and boy does it show.

I'd decided to at least read the second in the series, but after reading the preview included in the ebook I read, now I'm not so sure. It begins with Thanet's wife broaching the topic of returning to work once their youngest child starts school in six months. Thanet's internal thoughts on his wife going back to work and what it was going to mean for his ease and comfort of life kinda soured me on him.

I may check it out just to see if he cam redeem himself in my eyes.

I had not read any of the Detective Inspector Luke Thanet series before and I read these all at once. In the introduction to the first one, Ms Simpson explains that she spent her professional career as a marriage counselor and that she found some inspiration for her plots in the psychological insights she gained as a therapist. That admission coloured my reading of the books, as did my familiarity with the early run of Midsommer Murders, a long-running UK TV series.

Luke Thanet and Tom Barnaby share a smarminess about their home lives and marriages that I find repulsive. In the case of Luke Thanet, I read Ms Simpson's efforts to teach responsive marriage techniques and her idea of how a married man should act. She even drags DI Thanet's assistant, Mike Lineman, his controlling mother and his suffering wife into it. Yuck.

The mysteries are OK but nothing special.

I don't need this series.

I received review copies of "Close Her Eyes", "Puppet for a Corpse", and "Six Feet Under" by Dorothy Simpson (Open Road Integrated Media) through NetGalley.com.

I had not read any of the Detective Inspector Luke Thanet series before and I read these all at once. In the introduction to the first one, Ms Simpson explains that she spent her professional career as a marriage counselor and that she found some inspiration for her plots in the psychological insights she gained as a therapist. That admission coloured my reading of the books, as did my familiarity with the early run of Midsommer Murders, a long-running UK TV series.

Luke Thanet and Tom Barnaby share a smarminess about their home lives and marriages that I find repulsive. In the case of Luke Thanet, I read Ms Simpson's efforts to teach responsive marriage techniques and her idea of how a married man should act. She even drags DI Thanet's assistant, Mike Lineman, his controlling mother and his suffering wife into it. Yuck.

The mysteries are OK but nothing special.

I don't need this series.

I received review copies of "Close Her Eyes", "Puppet for a Corpse", and "Six Feet Under" by Dorothy Simpson (Open Road Integrated Media) through NetGalley.com.

I had not read any of the Detective Inspector Luke Thanet series before and I read these all at once. In the introduction to the first one, Ms Simpson explains that she spent her professional career as a marriage counselor and that she found some inspiration for her plots in the psychological insights she gained as a therapist. That admission coloured my reading of the books, as did my familiarity with the early run of Midsommer Murders, a long-running UK TV series.

Luke Thanet and Tom Barnaby share a smarminess about their home lives and marriages that I find repulsive. In the case of Luke Thanet, I read Ms Simpson's efforts to teach responsive marriage techniques and her idea of how a married man should act. She even drags DI Thanet's assistant, Mike Lineman, his controlling mother and his suffering wife into it. Yuck.

The mysteries are OK but nothing special.

I don't need this series.

I received review copies of "Close Her Eyes", "Puppet for a Corpse", and "Six Feet Under" by Dorothy Simpson (Open Road Integrated Media) through NetGalley.com.

Inspector Thanet investigates the murder of his local MP's mother, whose body is discovered during a fete at their country house. Despite the fact that there are hundreds of guests, it becomes clear that only a member of the family could have committed the crime.

This was a pretty run of the mill detective story. Thanet and his colleagues were normal people with happy marriages, which I always appreciate. It was a little dated in its attitudes to e.g. the roles of women and class, and also heavy-handed in its treatment of e.g. having a Downs Syndrome child or a child with dyslexia. The solution was perhaps slightly over the top, but it was foreshadowed competently. I wonder what happened with Pamela and Hugo...

I was ready for this story to be done. I have enjoyed others in the series more than this particular story.

Very excited to read more of Dorothy Simpson. Great writer.

Just another mystery.

Just another mystery.

Very good. I want to look for more by Dorothy Simpson. Suicide looks like murder -- is it?

Detective Inspector Luke Thanet investigates the murder of a young woman who had an unhappy marriage. The investigation grinds slowly and he thinks he should look all the way back to her childhood and that this murder may be linked to one the victim witnessed as a toddler. Fascinating look at the way the detective conducts his case and the several review processes that he goes through. At the same time he is mentoring a young detective. He is very introspective on his work and his life with a loving wife and two small children.

Somewhat tedious.

A woman Barrister returns home to discover her babysitter lying dead on the kitchen floor. Not only is the body lying in a pool of blood from a head wound,but a plastic bag is covering the head and face. Inspector Luke Thanet is quickly on the scene and together with his assistant Sergeant Lineham begins his investigation. The victim is found to be a young woman with domestic problems who is also a talented artist who has produced some unsettling works.
Slightly pedestrian in style,but notable for a detective with an interesting family life and the fact that the crime,although an unpleasant one,is cleverly solved.

quite good. too much introspection by thanet.

Inspector Luke Thanet investigates the murder of a womanizing travel writer whose body was found in the swimming pool at his own engagement party. The text became repetitive as clues were revisited so often. The conclusion was unsatisfying.

I've read most of her books and she is a good writer who doesn't go off on tangents.

For me, this book ticks all the boxes of a good whodunnit. The story catches one's attention quickly, moves at pace and provides an unexpected ending. This is all achieved without trickery - such as introducing a new character a few pages from the end, or an endless string of gory murders designed to renew a fading interest.

This is not great literature but, life would be a dull thing were all one's reading to be 'worthy', and this is certainly entertaining. Thoroughly recommended.

i really enjoyed this book until the ending. why wouldn't she go to the hospital where she would be safe? why did no one believe her? how was this person getting into her house--surely this is important?½

good but very similar to another simpson.½