In terms of an in-depth and well-researched work on the highly complex politics of Central Asia, I have to give this a *5. Being a rather lowbrow, non-politically astute person (albeit one with a fascination in this region), I have to say it took a concerted effort to get through it all. The author does her utmost to weave human interest stories into the events of the Afghan War and Tajik Civil War... but the complexity; the behind-the-scenes string pulling of Russia and the US; the puppet amir; the hotblooded islamic movements; the lies, propaganda and double-dealing left me with a kind of confused impression.
Perhaps the main thing that struck me was the huge interconnectedness of Uzbekistan, Tajikistan and ...what I always see as a separate entity...Afghanistan. People crossed the border constantly, as problems in one place led them to flee.
As the Taleban are rising in power (published 2003), I sort of gained a confused impression as to how the terrible mess that had arisen gave them a foothold. Certainly the superpowers have to shoulder their share of responsibility.
Very impressive research. Glad to finish though!!! ( )

http://amiralace.blogspot.com/2006/08/land-beyond-river.html ( )