This book starts out like a good Dumas story, and when he is describing the relationship between the "Mysterious Doctor" and the non-verbal, seemingly-uncomprehending child he takes under his care, the story moves along wonderfully. But around the middle of the book politics come into play, sweeping the doctor off the Paris to take part in the events. Dumas, who is usually such a master as blending historical fact and fiction, seems more like he's writing a history book. There were too many random names of generals and captains and just generally too much focus on the battles for my liking. This book is at its best when it focuses on the people affected by these tumultuous events. ( )