3L

What were your thoughts of Dr Moncrieff following his chat with Sandy? Any thoughts on how he reacted when asked if he was having an affair with Emma?

I think Dr. Moncrieff is hiding something and he is my #1 suspect.

He's hiding something I'm sure but somehow I don't see him as Emma's killer. I'm liking Martha more and more for that honor. Her brother could have helped her get the body to the barn and over the rafter. I believe that he may be trying to protecting his daughter and son.

I don't think he's a killer but he might have been involved with her.

He overreacted quite a lot with anger. You know what they say about someone who protests too much..... they're lying. He's definitely hiding something. I'd like him to be the killer but I think he's too obvious so maybe it's Martha and he's protecting her as >3 Carol420: says.

I've never liked the man, and this interview did nothing to change my mind. I think he took advantage of Emma, and is now sweating in case he's found out.

What a horrible objectionable man, he needs to be guilty so he goes to prison. Much as I want it to be him think it is being made too obvious for Ann Cleeves Books. Is he hiding an affair with Emma or plain outright abusing her!