Weird. In a good way. It is kinda short, and still feels slow sometimes, but those were the days back then... ( )

This novellete won the Hugo in '67 and the Nebular in '66, and it happens to be my very first reading of Jack Vance.

I expected nothing other than Silver Age SF, under-topics that were very important to the day, and what might seem to be very old tropes. So what did I get?

Silver Age SF, a fairly deeply buried reflection on a topic of "Doing The Job Yourself"... as opposed letting another class, be it race, socioeconomic, or sex, to do it for you. You know, American Work Ethic, and why the hell is everyone hiring maids to do all their housework, damnit? And of course we get the standard SF tropes that all you fans love, such as highly stratified societies and a huge War With Robots. Yeah! And don't forget castles and neat twists that make them seem almost like metaphors for tightly controlled generational ships.

The afterward tells us that he's bringing in some of the surface layers of Japanese Shogunate verbal niceties, too, so definitely keep an eye out in the read for that. :)

There's a ton of great ideas flitting and flying about here, and some of them have 2 foot wingspans even if they're craven cowards and don't want to dominate the text. Which is a shame, because the juxtaposition of all these tropes and a few more I haven't even mentioned is what makes this story a truly cool one.

Jack Vance was one hell of a talesmith, and I am thrilled enough to start building a collection right next to my tiny but growing shelf of Poul Anderson. Sweet!

Oh, and for those purists that hate to read old SF because of all the sexism, prejudice, and other cringeworthy social artifacts, don't worry yourselves with this one. It's pretty damn clean and interesting without being a misanthrope.

After all, the slaves get freed and the old masters have to get their crap together. :) ( )

This is a wonderful short story that focusses more on society and politics than on elaborate character building etc ...
A society that rather dies at the hand of their enemies then give up their possessions and status.
It's striking how much of this you can still see in today's real society.
Excellently written, not a typical sci-fi read but a great in-between-er ! ( )

Like Wells but with more fantasy elements. The Birds and Phanes were cool. A little dated but cool. Against slavery and elitism. ( )

While this has all the usual trappings of a Vance story - declining society, strange environment, weird creatures - it's unusual in leaning more toward the macho he-man resolution of its time than toward Vance's usual sardonic onlooker.

Award winner or not, I wouldn't put it in the same category as [b:The Languages of Pao|40889|The Languages of Pao|Jack Vance|http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1169512189s/40889.jpg|1877052] or [b:The Magnificent Showboats Of The Lower Vissel River Lune Xxiii South, Big Planet|6467260|The Magnificent Showboats Of The Lower Vissel River Lune Xxiii South, Big Planet|Jack Vance|http://www.goodreads.com/assets/nocover/60x80.png|6657766].

A good introduction to Vance, and a fun story for fans.

CVIE vol IV ( )