Abbott’s survey of celibacy throughout the ages and across the globe is a feminist take on the ways that celibacy has empowered some and crushed others. The first few chapters look at the celibacy from the Greeks and Romans through early and later Christianity. The book does tend to focus rather more on the West, but the author clearly made an effort to look at other cultures and religions. After a chapter examining other major religions, the book divides its look at celibacy by topic – celibacy to preserve semen, empower women, as a duty, for a cause, coerced etc. The last chapter picks up the more linear historical look at the 20th century. It’s a survey so sometimes there’s jumping around and each individual section is short – it would be easy to find more in-depth information about, for example, Elizabeth I and Florence Nightingale. However, the analysis of the benefits and drawbacks of celibacy is good and the nuanced situating of various forms of celibacy in context makes the book well worth reading.

Abbott is at her best in her vivid descriptions of the lives of strong, unconventional women – early Christians (real or apocryphal) who could be reformed prostitutes, desert-dwelling virgins or rebellious daughters; the Beguines, a loose spiritual community of women who did good deeds; Catherine of Siena – her extravagant asceticism gave her a power she could never have had in a conventional life but is also somewhat disturbing; powerful virgin priestesses – the Roman vestal virgins and the Incan acllas; Joan of Arc and the Crow warrior Woman Chief; artistic women in Boston marriages. For women who voluntarily chose to become celibate, the rewards could be immense – equal or superior status to men, control of their bodies and future, freedom from drudgery and childbirth. But of course many women were forced to remain chaste in some way – forced into a convent, victims of the double standard in multiple ways. Men who chose to be celibate often saw women as, at best, a distraction and at worst a sinful inferior being. Abbott is clearly writing from a feminist perspective. For the most part, she seems sympathetic to or at least gives a very good description of the power of the draw of celibacy. However, it is clear that patriarchal society and the church hierarchy are often the villains in her summaries. She notes “I seek spirituality in my religion, Christianity, but exploring its roots as I researched this book left me instead struggling to retain my religious faith.” Her contempt in some of the sections – on the role of Hindu widows, Chinese foot binding, female genital mutilation, American slaveholders and 19th c. English attitudes towards prostitution – comes through.

This being a history of celibacy, there are some queasily memorable bits – Abbott’s description of actual chastity belts, the horrifying-sounding impotence tests in pre-Revolutionary France, the multiple methods of castration that were described. Overall very interesting. ( )

Abbott’s treatise on all manners and varieties of celibacy throughout history is wide-ranging but not all-encompassing. Any such attempt would make the work doubly thick but not doubly rich. While some of her assertions cannot be entirely substantiated, they do not detract from the overall scholarship. An excellent start into this subject area. ( )

http://talesofarampaginglibrarian.blogspot.com/2007/03/rumors-of-my-dearth-have-... ( )

Not Read