There are very few Harrison books I don't like. This book was nominated for a Hugo Award in 1962. It's a good story for the early 1960s. I am being a little generous by giving it 4 stars but I admit it did hold my interest.

It brings up the dilemma of; should you try to save the people of a country, or planet that appears to have no redeeming qualities. ( )

How did Harrison write both this and the Eden trilogy? This book gets everything wrong---mutation, evolution, characterization, gender, brain damage---in a package as dry as a lab animal food pellet. The only thing I enjoyed was when it was over. ( )

Entertaining in a dated kind of way. ( )

Originally posted at FanLit.
http://www.fantasyliterature.com/reviews/planet-of-the-damned/

Brion Brandd has just become the champion of his planet by defeating all the other contestants in �??The Twenties.ƒ? Many men train all their lives for a chance to be the winner and Brion is ready to savor his victory. But not so fast! When a former winner challenges Brion to do something truly meaningful and heroic with his life, Brion sets off to save the planet Dis from a war that will surely destroy the entire planet. Dis has a hostile environment that nearly kills Brion before he even gets to meet the natives. Then he needs to figure out how the planet and the species that have evolved on it work together so he can solve their political problems.

Since this is a story written by Harry Harrison, there must also be a hot chick for Brion to save and fall in love with. My eyebrows rose when I found out that the girl in Planet of the Damned is Dr. Lea, an accomplished biologist. That was surprising after Harrison had just told us that men and women have to compete separately in The Twenties because ƒ??the inherent differences prevented fair contests. For example, it is impossible for a woman to win a large chess tournament and this fact was recognized.ƒ? (Itƒ??s true that all chess champions so far have been men, but men outnumber women in competitive chess 16:1. For some reason there are relatively few women who compete in chess. Perhaps itƒ??s lack of talent with that type of competitive and aggressive visual spatial task ƒ?? or just a simple lack of interest ƒ?? but to say itƒ??s a fact that itƒ??s impossible for a woman to win is ridiculous.)

Anyway, some of the men in the story are outraged that theyƒ??ve been sent a female scientist because they think sheƒ??ll ƒ??melt in the rain,ƒ? and Brion decides she must be carefully watched, but the hot chickƒ??s expertise is an important part of the plot after we get past all her shrieking, falling, fainting and being saved and carried around by Brion. Eventually, while sobbing, she decides she wants to get married and that sheƒ??s tired of being a biologist and a ƒ??mental match for any man.ƒ? (If she has a Ph.D. in exobiology, shouldnƒ??t she be more than a mental match for most men? Whatever, Mr. Harrison.)

Planet of the Damned is very similar to Harry Harrisonƒ??s Deathworld. Manly man goes to save planet, planet has hostile environment, nativesƒ?? evolution and symbiotic relationship with planet are key to solution, and thereƒ??s a hot chick to fall in love with for no particularly good reason. Itƒ??s unbelievable, cheesy, poorly written, pulpy and worst of all, boring. It might have been better if I hadnƒ??t felt like Iƒ??d already read this story in Deathworld. I keep giving Harry Harrison another try because I love several of his STAINLESS STEEL RAT books, but I think I might be done with Harrison now. (Three strikes and youƒ??re out!)

Planet of the Damned was originally serialized and then published as a novel in 1962. It has also been published as Sense of Obligation. I listened to the audio version which was produced by Jimcin Recordings in 2010 and has been recently released on CD by Brilliance Audio. Jim Roberts does his usual slightly wooden but competent narration. Planet of No Return is another Harrison novel that features Brion Brandd. ( )

Fairly standard space opera - stop a war, save a planet, etc. However, it was done very well. True classic sf. ( )