I loved this novella the best out of all three, don't get me wrong all of them have been amazing but I think Teddy stole my heart. Noel was funny, hardworking, and my favorite Winter sister. She meets Teddy the day she is helping out with a picture with Santa day and meets Teddy thinks he is her coworkers brother and forces him into the Santa suit. Teddy is this charismatic, handsome guy who is highly attracted to Noel almost immediately, he sets out to get to know her more but wires get crossed, things aren't what they seem and Teddy isn't exactly who Noel thought he was. I loved this so much and the sweetness of "tell me a secret" part was adorable. Great read! ( )

Of all the books in the Reindeer Falls Collection, I found The One Night Stand Before Christmas the most relatable. Maybe it's the older sister syndrome that comes with Noel being the eldest, or with her history of relationships, it's hard to make an intelligent guess. However rare mistaken identity may be in real life, it's an adorable trope that, when executed correctly, can do wonders for a book. And it's done just right in this book. The book also offers a glance into its predecessors, which makes me happy to get closure and learn more about Holly and Ginger. Despite being a bit unusual, Theo (Teddy) and Noel are made for each other and are definitely my top Christmas couple so far. ( )

I completely adore this series of short Christmas novellas set in Reindeer Falls by Jana Aston. Each one features a different sister finding love around the holidays and they’re all completely adorable. In this one (book three), Noel has a one-night stand with a mystery Santa (Teddy) and sparks fly from there. Noel works at a senior center as an activities director (fun!) and Teddy steps in to put on the red suit at the last second. After a wild night and some miscommunication, can the two of them work things out? This was a great conclusion to the series.

Please excuse typos/name misspellings. Entered on screen reader.
( )

finally finished this series! it was cute and super quick read with one of my fave tropes-mistaken identity! ( )

There is no harm in reading a cute short story. This series basically a no brainer reading.

I like it. Suitable for my holiday mood. ( )