Fascinating subject earnestly written about by a young man whose observations are not as interesting as he thinks they are, and whose knowledge is inadequate to the task. For example: Nancollas shares with the reader, halfway through the text, that his researches have revealed to him there is a knot called a bowline. Peppered with rather tedious poeticisms and arty pseudo-profundities. Sorry Tom. I blame your editor. It's great to be published by Penguin (look at the quotes the PR department got for your cover!) but this would have been a better a book had it been more about lighthouses, as commercially dry a publishing prospect as that is, and less about yourself. Sadly publishers these days always want the author in the frame. Perhaps I am just jealous, or there is some sort of nepotism afoot. In any case publishers are wrong. Even Bill Bryson, a supremely charming writer, keeps himself further out of his texts than today's biographical scriveners. ( )

Lighthouses lost a little of their romance when they became fully automated solar-powered machines. They have a long history though as beacons to guide sailors safely around the coast. Even with modern technology like GPS fitted to ships, they are still relevant and necessary. There are over 60 lighthouses in the UK, my nearest is in Portland Bill in Dorset. This is a coastal one, but this book is about the handful that are built on tiny outcrops of rock standing against the might of the sea and everything that is thrown at it.

Nancollas had originally trained as a building conservationist before falling for lighthouses and rock lighthouses in particular. All eight of the lighthouses that he writes about in here have stories still to tell. He is fascinated by the men who conceived and designed them to be able to face the strongest waves and winds, by how they were built and the ones that didn’t survive and were rebuilt. He teases apart their histories and heads out to sea to get first-hand experience as to what it was like to travel to these places. However, as resilient as they are, they are not totally self-sufficient and still rely on care and maintenance from us. He even undertakes crash training in a helicopter simulator so he can travel out to stay in the Fastnet lighthouse for a week while a generator is serviced and rebuilt.

I thought that this book was excellent, it has a strong narrative like all good non-fiction should and it is well researched, not only from behind a desk but his experiences bobbing up and down on a boat travelling to visit them. It has a personal element too, not only is he obsessed by them, but he found a link to the construction of one of the lighthouses following some research into his family tree. I particularly liked the interlude where he visits the lighthouse in Blackwall, London where they experimented and tried various pieces of new kit out prior to dispatching them to the lighthouses around the UK. If you have a thing about lighthouses, then I’d also recommend Stargazing by Peter Hill too. ( )

A really readable and accessible short book looking at isolated rock light houses around the coasts of both Britain & Ireland. Combining history with some technical data this is popular history and engineering at its best. Obviously the authors fascination and obsession with light houses beams through and one can’t help but be carried along by it. Very good. Recommended for the lay reader and enthusiast alike. ( )