Laurence Tribe is a professor at Harvard Law School who specializes in constitutional law. Among his many publications is the seminal treatise, American Constitutional Law. Joshua Matz, a graduate of Harvard Law School, has collaborated with Tribe in a previous book, Uncertain Justice. Singly and together, they know whereof they speak when they discuss constitutional law.

In To End a Presidency: The Power of Impeachment, Tribe and Matz once again collaborate on an especially important legal issue of the day. Or perhaps I should say, “political issue,” because they themselves admit there is very little law governing impeachment, and what there is, is not terribly precise.

This book, published in 2018, treats impeachment from a largely historical perspective. They do not believe the Constitution calls for a simple trial to determine whether “bribery, treason, high crimes or misdemeanors” occurred as a matter of law, followed by a yes-or-no vote which then either acquits or finds the president guilty as charged. Instead, they see the process as one that calls for political rather than legal judgment at every step of the procedure, from the decision of the House of Representatives to charge an impeachment, through the “trial” where the Senate sits in judgement.

They argue that Congress has the responsibility to weigh the potential bad consequences of an impeachment (e.g., will it initiate a civil war?; will it empower an even more incompetent or corrupt vice president?) against the need to remove a bad actor from the highest office of the land. They emphasize the power of Congress to refrain from acting even in the face of technically and legally impeachable acts. Moreover, they stress that impeachment was meant to be a very big deal, not to be undertaken lightly.

Yet, as any regular viewer of MSNBC or CNN knows, currently Tribe is vigorously advocating the impeachment and removal from office of Donald Trump. For one thing, the book was published in 2018, before the details of the Ukraine scandal became known. More importantly, the authors’ historical analysis showed that Trump’s behavior probably merited impeachment even without reference to Ukraine. On Tribe’s twitter feed (@tribelaw) he now says of Trump’s behavior (in particular, firing the national intelligence chief for speaking about Russia’s preference for Trump and interference in our elections on his behalf):

“This truly looks like TREASON in all but the narrowest possible sense. If confirmed, it’s utterly devastating. It points to an enemy of the nation sitting in the White House. This cannot stand if we are to survive as a sovereign constitutional republic.”

Evaluation: To End a Presidency is an excellent, crisply written analysis of the history and state of the law of impeachment in the early 21st Century. It should have been required reading for all the talking heads who covered the proceedings on television.

(JAB) ( )

This is an excellent look at the issue of impeachment from both a historical and political perspective. The authors provide the reader with a great deal of important and insightful information on this legislative power, as well as advice on when to use it and when not to. It was written before Trump was impeached, but it was almost scary how accurate the authors were when they predicted what the outcome of such an impeachment effort would be based on the composition of the Senate and the mood of the country. They point out that sometimes the only remedy is for the American people to vote which we will do this year. I highly recommend this book! ( )

Excellent examination of the difficulties and perils of impeachment. ( )

Outstanding book by Laurence Tribe and Joshua Matz about the topic of impeachment. Anyone interested in gaining a better understanding of the impeachment process and its ramifications can't go wrong taking the time to read this well written and very informative book. ( )

I have known of Lawrence Tribe for a long while but only started following him on Twitter for about six months. His voice of reason, on Twitter of all places, a venue not known for reasoned thought, impressed me enough to preorder his book “To end a presidency : the power of impeachment” . Like his posts on Twitter the book is thoughtful and informative. It is also less partisan than I expected. Even a Trump supporter can read this book without suffering a sudden case of the vapors.

I was not expecting an in depth look at the history of the development and use of impeachment but is there a better way to understand the concept and its implications? I expected a passionate plea to remove Trump, instead Tribe and his co-author Joshua Matz examine the Framers “intent” the only way possible, by looking at what they wrote and the revisions they made while crafting the Constitution.

The Constitution says that all high civil officers of the United States can be impeached for “Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors”. That starts off very explicitly but as Tribe points out “other high Crimes and Misdemeanors” can cover almost anything. We have never removed a president through impeachment. That could be because the degree of cooperation required is beyond the ability of our legislative branch. It could also be that the members of the legislature understand that removing a president before their term expires could inspire violence from that administration’s supporters.

Tribe repeats that idea throughout the book. A president’s supporters might resort to violence if they feel that politics if the only reason for the impeachment. Which is why Mueller's investigation is so important. Unless the voters understand that there was/is serious wrongdoing we could end up with more violence than in 1968 or 1876. That is also why Trump keeps yelling “FAKE NEWS”, he is trying to assure that his supporters will not believe any incriminating evidence against him.

I doubt that this book would have been written without Trump in the White House but it is definitely not aimed at him. I was less fond of the idea of his impeachment after reading it. The book is a through look at the legal and political history of Article II Section 4 of the Constitution. Whatever your opinion of this President this book is worth your time. ( )