Good plot and characters. Novel is moving; sad and yet hopeful.

But parts felt stilted, forced, watered-down and inauthentic Makes me wonder if novel is geared to readers, young or old, with little knowledge of the Holocaust.

Johann Blumenthal is a German silversmith, a talented silversmith who counts both Gentiles and his fellow Jews among his regular customers. Filled with love for a homeland that doesn’t always love him back, he enlists in the German Army to fight in World War I. Before he leaves, he crafts an exquisite silver music box for his young son, Paul, to remember him by. When Johann doesn’t return from the front, Paul and his mother, Lotte, are left to pick up the pieces with the help of Uncle Max, also a talented jeweler.

Fast-forward to the 1930s. Paul, now a young adult, is still captivated by his father’s music box. He’s also captivated by Clara, a doctor’s daughter who longs to be teacher, an occupation closed to those of her religion. So she determines to convert to Christianity in order to fulfill her dreams. Paul does the same in order to be with the love of his life, and for a while all is well. Of course, we know that things don’t stay that way. As life in Germany gets increasingly more difficult and dangerous for Jews, the Blumenthals looks for ways to protect themselves from the coming storm. Each of them — Lotte, Uncle Max, Aunt Martha, and Paul and Clara — seek different paths to safety.

I wasn’t in the best head space to read historical fiction about the run-up to the Holocaust, to be honest, but I was invested enough in the characters and story to keep reading, and I’m glad I did. The narrative takes a big leap in time from 1939 to 1963, content to fill in the tragic details in the form of a later descendant of the family searching for her roots. This lightened the tension, which I appreciated.

It’s a good story, perhaps a bit simplistically told, but captures well the growing fear of the German Jewish community as the Nazis grow in strength and power during the lead up to World War II. ( )

I absolutely loved the first 2/3 of this book. The story was beautiful and heartbreaking, and the writing was perfection. I was so invested in the family and their story, and went through so many emotions while I was reading. But all of that fell apart when it came to Lillian's portion of the story, the modern-day section. Everything began to feel rushed, as if Baites wasn't quite sure what she wanted to say and just wanted the book to be over. It didn't ruin the book for me, but it did lower my overall opinion of it some. It was disappointing to go from such a strong, emotional beginning to a lackluster ending. The second book in the series is set to be published, but I have no plans to read it, unfortunately. ( )

A beautifully written book about a Jewish family in Germany. The story covers three generations spanning both world wars. A recommended read. ( )

So good!

I could not put this story down. While it is not long, I read this book in under 12 hours. What a compelling, heart breaking story told with emotions leaping off the page. It is a unique look at the Holocaust and the struggles of Jews in Germany. Highly recommended! ( )