Foto dell'autore
6 opere 272 membri 7 recensioni

Opere di Adrian Raine

Etichette

Informazioni generali

Non ci sono ancora dati nella Conoscenza comune per questo autore. Puoi aiutarci.

Utenti

Recensioni

Edit: I have followed this up with Behave by Robert M Sapolsky and it completely puts this book to shame. I still don't think this book is awful, but the fact that there's a book that basically covers everything this book does, is better structured and written, gives a better idea of what's well backed vs speculation, and does it in more depth knocks a star off here for me. Maybe it's unfair because it's a couple years newer and didn't exist when this book was written, but there's really no reason to read this book over behave. Even at significantly longer length, it manages to be an easier, more coherent read.

**
This one is interesting. There’s a lot here backed by evidence, and overall the book takes an interesting look at how various changes to brain structure/development (from early malnutrition or abuse to genetics to physical trauma) tend to result in a higher rates of criminal behavior, with the focus on violent and sexual crimes. But it’s intermixed with bits here and there of jankiness that’s less supported. When he gets to the final subject discussing the ethics and future steps, he goes off the rails a bit for me. “Your brain made you read this book” is a weird argument that free will is nonsense even if he comes around a little later, and his argument that we should treat the person with a clear tumor basis for wildly out of character behavior the same as someone with a slightly smaller brain region is really uncomfortable. Then I’m not entirely sure he’s not advocating a Minority Report style precrime intervention system when he uses it to raise questions.


Overall, though, I am convinced by the case that we should be focusing on proper nutrition and mental health access and that the better we take care of our kids, as a society, the less likely they are to turn to violence. I think even with its flaws, it does encourage you to think about things that we should probably think about.
… (altro)
 
Segnalato
jdm9970 | 6 altre recensioni | Jan 26, 2023 |
I heard the author on NPR Fresh Air a few months ago and was intrigued enough to pick up the book when I saw it at my local library. I suspected that it might fall into the "pushing the science too far" trap, especially with brain imaging and neuroscience, but pushed ahead anyway. Biology must have some role, somewhere along the line, to play--culture didn't spring fully formed without it.

The book opens really, really badly with a trip down the evolutionary psychology wormhole. The problem with ev psych is simple: You observe certain differences in populations. Then you come up with an evolutionary hypothesis to explain it. The problem is, of course, it's difficult if not impossible to prove that hypothesis. Raine steps into a veritable greatest perils of ev-psych, from explaining rape to slapdash anthropology.

The book climbs onto slightly firmer ground in subsequent chapters--at least, here, Raine has some data to work with. The problem is, the data is still in its infancy and despite frequent caveats and reminders of the interaction between biology and environment, he's too quick to rush to conclusions with preliminary data. Despite all the hype about brain imaging, and the very real information it has given us, we still have a long way to go.

The potentially strongest part of the book is on the interaction between biological and social factors. Raine is most convincing when he demonstrates how biology is more than just genetics and evolution, and is also the result of environment. His examples of how poor social factors can influence biology and that parenting and social climate can combine with biological risk factors to influence outcomes get at the real complexity of the situation. For example, he looks at groups of teens with both biological and social risk factors for violence and shows how the combination is far more potent than either risk factor alone.

That said, he also relies too heavily on what may be questionable research (such as the potential of omega-3 supplementation). He is also not above provocation for the sake of it, such as armchair-diagnosing Adam Lanza with a personality disorder, and obligatory potshots at feminists.

The final chapter is a mess. Raine wants to outline a potential future for the uses of neurobiological research. First, he throws out the idea of considering violence as a mental disorder. Then he outlines a dystopic future of precrime detention, child intervention, and parenting licenses before stepping back to ask if this is already happening to some extent and what it means. Raine himself has no great answers--his best effort throughout the book is that his research shows the importance of interventions for very young children, a principle that research into other domains of development has shown--and so he is left flailing.

Raine is a fairly good, if sometimes overly personal and chatty, writer, and there is some interesting information in here, but the book as a whole does not work. I am not familiar enough with much of the research he cites to say whether the individual studies are presented accurately, but he gives the impression that he is overstating his case.
… (altro)
 
Segnalato
arosoff | 6 altre recensioni | Jul 11, 2021 |
It's a fascinating topic but this book is badly written. Both in terms of style and lack of substance. Anecdotes are told in great detail whilst the studies mentioned lack basic information about them.
 
Segnalato
Paul_S | 6 altre recensioni | Dec 23, 2020 |
This in-depth book about the science of the brain and what psychological factors incite violence is extremely interesting and should be a top five for any science-loving bookworms! It took a bit of convincing to get my auntie to buy me it, but it truly is a good choice for whoever is interested in psychology.
1 vota
Segnalato
WheresTheBeef | 6 altre recensioni | Jan 19, 2016 |

Liste

Premi e riconoscimenti

Potrebbero anche piacerti

Statistiche

Opere
6
Utenti
272
Popolarità
#85,118
Voto
3.8
Recensioni
7
ISBN
28
Lingue
5

Grafici & Tabelle