The best book on Populists and the reality of their so called prejudices. Very concise research on the participation of ethnic groups in Kansas. Lays out the economic reasons for the farmers participation. Good background for anyone interested in Capitalism in America. New edition available.

Segnalato

M.Esping | Jan 18, 2014 |

Habits of Empire: A History of American Expansion di Walter Nugent

Frontier Thesis Examined

A comprehensive survey of American imperialism since the revolutionary period through to the twentieth century. "Habits of Empire" by Walter Nugent is a rare look into the motivations behind manifest destiny, the frontier thesis, and American exceptionalism.

Nugent is primarily concerned with expansionism in the nineteenth century, beginning with Jefferson's "empire for liberty" statement through until McKinley's Empire II. Much has been written about modern American imperialism so Nugent purposely excludes this period, though he includes a short chapter on contemporary imperialism at the end.

The book is especially strong in the areas of American territorial negotiations resulting from the treaties to end the revolutionary war, giving Benjamin Franklin the primary credit for the coup over both the British and the French. Jefferson's Louisiana purchase and the failed attempt to annex Canada in the War of 1812 is also well covered by Nugent. As the book approaches the Mexican war, Oregon and 54-40, Alaska, and the Spanish-American War, the source analysis gets a little thinner.

"Habits of Empire" is primarily a political and military history. Nugent uses plenty of original archival sources from the Library of Congress and most of the chronological and documentary analysis is spot on.

Though Nugent does discuss some of the underlying social, cultural, religious and racial motives behind ideologies such as Frederick Jackson Turner's Frontier Thesis, manifest destiny, American exceptionalism, the Monroe Doctrine, and the Roosevelt Corollary. I think that Nugent should have included more research on these ideologies as they form the bedrock of why American expansionism is an ideology and not simply an ephemeral policy of realpolitik.

Economics and technology are also under-explored by Nugent. One major factor for American expansionism was Jefferson's introduction of the six square mile townships. Large infrastructure investments such as the Eerie Canal or the main railway networks are also sparsely discussed. Finally, the discovery of gold in California in 1848 is omitted altogether.

With that said, for such an important and relevant topic, the book is historically significant in outlining a longstanding faith in the inevitable progress and rhetoric of spreading freedom and democracy which we hear so often whether it is JFK's New Frontier or the Bush Doctrine.

Overall, I recommend the book despite its flaws because of the importance of the subject to contemporary analysis of America's position in the world. The book is not written for an academic audience and so is therefore easy to read.… (altro)

Segnalato

bruchu | Nov 23, 2008 |

Vedi altre recensioni