Ian Gardner (1)

This book is by a pair of men who recorded the story of a little-known event in WWII history, so obscure that most WWII historians can't even tell you where it happened exactly.

Most of us are familiar with the Band of Brothers and other books/movies like that, of course, and I was hoping for a similar narrative of the 3rd Btl 506 PIR and the events of D-Day and the taking of vital two bridges held by the Germans, but it's written like a cold documentary with little emotion. It was a struggle to read; the author would write a few paragraphs then insert a little paragraph-long anecdote that may or may not have been about the subject the author was addressing at that time. Very tedious writing style, to be sure.

Nonetheless, it is a fascinating topic, and little known. Knowing that someone lived through these events is emotional and motivational, and the book is well worth the struggle to read.… (altro)

3.25-3.5 Stars
A detailed biography of Ed Shames during WWII. If you haven't read many E Company or 101st Airborne histories, then this book is an excellent start. The chronological descriptions are very thorough. At times, the writing is a bit technical or dry, but there are some good mini stories mixed in here and there. It's interesting to see where Ed Shames' story merged with the popular ones known throughout the world, but nice when it splits off to something new as well. There are some great photos included and a good sources list (primary and secondary) at the end which is perfect for further reading.

Net Galley Feedback… (altro)