Immagine dell'autore.
7+ opere 63 membri 1 recensione

Sull'Autore

Fonte dell'immagine: Geoff Emberling [credit: University of Chicago Service League]

Opere di Geoff Emberling

Opere correlate

Etichette

Informazioni generali

Utenti

Recensioni

A collection of essays released in conjunction with a 2010 exhibition at the Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago. The "and beyond" of the subtitle feels like an aftertought, with a single essay each on early Chinese and Maya writing - the latter seems particularly out of place as Maya writing, unlike Sumerian, Chinese, and (most probably) Egyptian, didn't originate independently, but was clearly inspired by earlier Mesoamerican scripts.

The pieces on cuneiform, Egyptian hieroglyphs, and the early alphabet are quite good, and really do focus on the invention or origin of the systems. Something I suspect is little appreciated is that from what's usually spoken of as the "first writing" in the late 4th millennium BC it took centuries until either hieroglyphs or cuneiform was used to write connected text with complete sentences - earlier writing consisted solely of isolated phrases, such as names, or stereotyped records where the reader had to supply details like verbs from context. The "invention of writing" was thus a very drawn-out process if one by writing understands something functionally like the modern form.

The essays on Hieratic, Demotic, Coptic and Anatolian hieroglyphs (aka Hieroglyphic Luwian/Hittite) are decent, but give a vague impression of mostly being included out of a sense of completeness. Hieratic separates from hieroglyphs very early on, but Coptic - a derivative of the Greek alphabet and younger than the Latin one - is surely very far from any origin of writing.
… (altro)
1 vota
Segnalato
AndreasJ | Jun 14, 2016 |

Liste

Potrebbero anche piacerti

Autori correlati

Gil J. Stein Foreword
Diane Hanau-Strain Cover designer
Vincent Francigny Contributor
Artur Obłuski Contributor
Henriette Hafsaas Contributor
Michele R. Buzon Contributor
Pawel Wolf Contributor
Ulrike Nowotnick Contributor
Charles Bonnet Contributor
Masoj Mirosaw Contributor
Friederike Jesse Contributor
Kathryn Howley Contributor
Claudia Näser Contributor
Kate Liszka Contributor
Aaron de Souza Contributor
Georg K. Meurer Contributor
Janice W. Yellin Contributor
Mahmoud El-Tayeb Contributor
Intisar Soghayroun Contributor
Jérôme Dubosson Contributor
Leilani Lucas Contributor
Jane Humphris Contributor
Laurel Bestock Contributor
Grzegorz OchaŁa Contributor
Matthieu Honegger Contributor
Derek A. Welsby Contributor
Dominique Valbelle Contributor
Stuart Tyson Smith Contributor
James A. Harrell Contributor
Jacke Phillips Contributor
Timothy Kendall Contributor
Jay Spaulding Contributor
Martin Williams Contributor
David N Edwards Contributor
Jeremy Pope Contributor
Henryk Paner Contributor
Dorian Q. Fuller Contributor
Bogdan Żurawski Contributor
Angelika Lohwasser Contributor
Donatella Usai Contributor
Adam Łajtar Contributor
Julia Budka Contributor
Krzysztof Grzymski Contributor
Rachael J. Dann Contributor
Claude Rilly Contributor
Luc Gabolde Contributor
Rebecca Bradshaw Contributor
Andrea Manzo Contributor
McGuire Gibson Contributor
Markus Dohner Designer

Statistiche

Opere
7
Opere correlate
4
Utenti
63
Popolarità
#268,028
Voto
3.9
Recensioni
1
ISBN
7

Grafici & Tabelle