Wyatt Earp

Going into this book, my only knowledge about Wyatt Earp came from Hollywood and film such as Tombstone and Gunfight at the O.K. Corral. I'm sure Earp aficionados are able to appreciate some of the subtleties of the book more, nonetheless, a novice like myself was able to get into the book and I did come away with a greater understanding of the scope of the legend of Earp and the famous shoot-out in Tombstone. The book's greatest appeal I feel lies in its wonderful presentation, a real testament to the publisher Fall River Press. Everything from the use of fonts, to the pictures, and the footnotes and sidebar quotations are very easy to follow and presents a modernly stylish look to an old subject. Although most of the book focuses on the Tombstone events, quite a bit illustrates later events in Earp's life such as his boxing referee days and his association with early motion picture star Tom Mix. Reading the primary sources really gives the reader a feel for how people spoke in the late 1880s and 90s, making the story come alive in a unique way. Its always fascinating to see how misinformation and lies spread so quickly through the press and defamation of character was as widespread as the lawlessness one sees depicted in old westerns. This book provides a very vivid portrait of the 'Old West' as it really was.… (altro)

To be certain, there are those who will sit there and pick this book apart, claiming that this is just another author looking to glorify Wyatt, Virgil, and Morgan Earp along with Doc Holliday and Bat Masterson thrown in for good measure. However, there is no denying that John Richard Stephens, the true author, took great pains and did a very thorough job of researching the Gunfight near the OK Corral, all that led up to it, the aftermath, and other occurrences aside. Stephens goes to as much first source material as he can not to aggrandize the Earps and their friends, but to allow them to speak to us in their own words. In fact, he leaves their words alone, allowing them to stand on their own merit, then adds a copious amount of footnotes to correct for errors, not only in language, but in how events are believed to have actually happened. After all, all of our memories are fallible and subject to change here and there through the passage of time. What is especially nice is that you can get a good feel for how some of these legendary men spoke and thought of themselves and their deeds, which then are given a reality check through footnotes. A very worthwhile read.… (altro)

A pretty well put together book, chock full of photos, scrutinized history and first hand accounts from the various players through interviews, depositions and newspapers articles. The editor basically let's the parties involved and articles written speak for themselves, but also notes the discrepancies as well as historical perspectives for each of the chapters. Footnoted quite well too. I have been looking for a book like this about Earp and the whole O.K. Corral affair and I really enjoyed it. Well done and recommended.… (altro)