Jay Timothy Dolmage
Autore di Academic Ableism: Disability and Higher Education (Corporealities: Discourses Of Disability)
Sull'Autore
Jay Timothy Dolmage is Associate Professor of English at the University of Waterloo and author of the award-winning book Disability Rhetoric.
Opere di Jay Timothy Dolmage
Etichette
Informazioni generali
Non ci sono ancora dati nella Conoscenza comune per questo autore. Puoi aiutarci.
Utenti
Recensioni
Premi e riconoscimenti
Statistiche
- Opere
- 4
- Utenti
- 108
- Popolarità
- #179,297
- Voto
- 3.9
- Recensioni
- 2
- ISBN
- 10
I am personally affected by a disability and administratively work at an academic medical center. My wife has taught special education for over a decade. My only sister has an intellectual disability. Despite five years of work, I was unable to complete a doctorate because of my disability. Therefore, I’m very sympathetic to this issue.
However, Dolmage spends almost all of the book compiling complaints about how short the academy is falling when trying to meet the needs of those with disabilities. I find four parts of this argument particularly troublesome.
First, much of his critique relies on identifying historical traces of eugenics. No doubt, some of this sad history is still with us, but eugenics has been repudiated by just about every reputable intellectual institution since the Nazi crimes in the mid-twentieth century. I need newer information than arguing that its ghost remains.
Second, he spends a whole chapter on how disabilities in higher education are portrayed in movies. Art certainly provides a healthy mirror to learn about our true nature, but I would prefer some rigorous science to back this up with hard data.
Third, the ADA is treated through a wholly negative lens, as mere window-dressing that doesn’t address the real problem. Perhaps, this is so in higher education – I plead ignorance there. However, in American society, I remember seeing a real difference in the way my sister was able to pursue life after 1990. My wife has also observed dramatic impacts on her students’ lives through the ADA. From an academic researcher, I expect a significantly more nuanced analysis.
Finally, the entire book compiles complaints about universities’ shortcomings, but provides almost no insights on solutions, which are limited to 2-3 pages. Correctly diagnosing a problem indeed provides the first step of a solution, but as a reader, I hoped to learn more about potential solutions from this book. Thus, I suggest that it needs to be reorganized with more details on what can be done practically.
I find this topic deeply interesting, but again, I hope to focus on present-day solutions based on serious reflection. This book contains a lot of rhetoric pointing towards a real problem, but it won’t convince many in decision-making positions to change their mind and practice. It won’t help us all reform ourselves so as to do better. I suggest a follow-up book might engage with promising next steps, not limited to a few linked articles in an epilogue.… (altro)