Richard Blackaby

This book was written by the father-son team of Henry and Richard Blackaby. Having led various organizations, large and small, in the church, they have the background to write on spiritual leadership, though I found myself dissatisfied with how they approached the topic--dissatisfied enough for some introspection on why. Here are my reasons (and I'll try to be brief):

The Blackabys wrote eleven chapters on leadership, entitled "The Leaders...Challenge, Role, Preparation, Vision, Character, Goal, Influence, Decision-Making, Schedule, Pitfalls and Rewards." About half way through the book, I found myself remarking (to myself), "This reads like any of the hundred other leadership books I've read with some Biblical or Spiritual material thrown in to illustrate the subject." Pick up almost any book by any author on leadership and you can find similar chapters and subjects. I expected a fresh look at leadership as described and illustrated in Scripture. Instead I was reading just another book on the same old topics.

At some places where the Blackabys had the opportunity to distinguish spiritual leadership (and their book) from the normal literature, they failed. As an example, this was their comment on Joseph: "There may not be anything overtly spiritual about building grain storage bins or developing a food distribution system, but these activities were on God's agenda." Here, they missed the opportunity to describe all work as God's work, all work as sacred. Work was God's creation and gift to Adam and Eve--before the fall--so any work, properly viewed, is overtly spiritual and sacred.

Likewise, at one point they make this important point: "...what 'success' means in God's kingdom...is not measured by the same standards as the world uses." Yet again and again in the book the appeal to the standards of the world as examples of good leadership.

At other places where they are describing leadership as many others have before (and since) their book, they seemed unaware of their message. This from the third chapter ("The Leader's Preparation"): "...but ultimately leadership is more about 'being' than doing" followed immediately after the second chapter entitled, "The Leader's Role: What Leaders Do". Much later in the book, discussing Lee Iacocca, they write, "His reputation was not enough. Leadership begins with 'being' but ultimately turns to 'doing.' It is not one's credentials but one's performance that ultimately confirms a person as a leader." Performance is a measure of doing. Leadership performance is almost always measured against the standards of the world. In writing about Iacocca, they undermined their own message.

Finally, in the chapter on a Leader's Pitfalls, the authors suggest five "safeguards" against sexual sin (accountability, heed their own counsel, contemplate the consequences, develop healthy habits, and pray). All are valuable; they are useful tools. But they are, by themselves, insufficient as they are all defensive and aimed at "not sinning." Having worked with several men who have struggled with sexual sin, I know these defensive measures are easily defeated, ignored and sidestepped by one bent on sin. History, ancient and current, is full of cautionary examples. Without a heart radically inclined to the pursuit of God and His character, His standards, all the defensive measures in the world won't work. I wish the authors had spent more time on a leader's pursuit of holiness. Which led to my own introspection.

Because of my growing dissatisfaction as I read, I spent some time thinking on the problem. Why do people read books on leadership? Because they desire to be a leader or to sharpen their leadership skills. These are good reasons and I can think of several books better than this one to fulfill those needs. But what about spiritual leadership? I pondered the most famous Biblical leaders. Who were they? How did they become an exceptional leader?

Abraham, they guy snatched up out of Ur and told by God to "Go...to a place I will show you."

Moses, the reluctant leader who argued with God for several chapters about his qualifications to lead, finally saying "send someone else!"

Samuel, called to leadership off his bed as a young boy.

David, the seventh son relegated to watch the sheep.

Jeremiah, whom God called from the womb who also argued with God about his youth.

Ezekiel, the prophet wandering in exile by the Khebar Canal whom God called and promised the people would not listen to him (how's that for an ordination?).

Saul, the enemy of God radically redirected by God on the road to Damascus.

None of these sought to be a leader of God's people. None likely read a single word on leadership skills. If we want great leaders in today's church, perhaps we should be redirecting them from books on leadership to the radical pursuit of God and listening for His still small voice. God will choose the next great leader of His people. Because our faces are buried in the latest popular book on leadership, we'll be surprised about who it is.… (altro)

When I was at the Southern Baptist Convention in St. Louis I had the opportunity to attend the North American Mission Board's Replanting Conference. Richard Blackaby was the guest speaker on Saturday Night, and they gave out copies of his book "Flickering Lamps." As I understand it this was written to encourage those in church revitalization and replanting. As the majority of churches in North America are plateaued or declining, Blackaby tells some of the story of his dad, author Henry Blackaby, and the challenges they faced as Henry moved the family to Canada to pastor a small run down church. They moved to Faith Baptist Church, that had a for sale sign out front! Some faith! It's a hopeful and encouraging story that is short on how-to's and long on Jesus and the Spirit. I think every church lead would be encouraged by this book, and will be drawn close to Christ because of it. Below are a few quotes that I pulled out.

Jesus is the one who closes churches, not the world.

The key's to glorifying God are first to love God, and second, to love God in God's way.

Any church that is not exalting Christ by it behavior has lost it's reason to exist.

It's arrogant to assume that God seeks to be glorified, to make disciples of all nations, yet he left the local church to figure out the details.

When you are suffering decline, you can't afford the consequences of enlisting ineffective leaders.

A church is in a precarious position when the phrase "we can't afford to" is spoken more than "God is leading us to."

A church's measure of success is the glory it brings to God.

The land is littered with churches that have been torn apart because people treated the church as if it belonged to them rather than to God.

The church is not called to do good things, but God things.… (altro)

Yes, there are some lessons from God's word about raising a family, mixed with some insightful questions, but this book suffers from a few fatal flaws. First, it relies greatly upon the Experiencing God Bible Study, which is plugged a number of times. Secondly, it has a significant amount of filler material consisting mostly of Blackaby family stories. Now, I like a good story that makes a point, but after a while you begin to feel like this family has almost no stories that center on someone other than them. The book takes on a feeling of being a family memoir rather than a Christian family-living Bible study. Finally, there are a number of pointers to other books written by various family members, and after all the reliance upon Experiencing God (by their father), the numerous family stories, and the recommendations of other Blackaby family books, this book begins to feel a bit like family self-promotion. Ray Comfort's "How to bring your children to Christ and keep them their is a much shorter and more useful read.… (altro)