As Maggie Mitchell enters her final semester of college, the last thing she wants is a guy in her life, let alone two of them. Her new lab partner, Sawyer Reed, is still the overconfident and sexy jock that made fun of her in high school. The only thing that has changed is that he now uses a wheelchair, the result of a skiing accident. Jude Marino is a hot actor, who all the girls want and would do anything to get. He works at a local theater where Maggie has been assigned to complete community services hours after rear-ending a police car. Sawyer and Jude want Maggie but only one of them will be able to capture her heart.