Read it twice. ( )

This is the book in which I read the story of Lance Corporal John Harmon. Alone he attacked a Japanese machine gun position. Then hoisting the captured gun over his head he walked back to his lines. The next day he did it again. On the third day as he was again completing the feat a sniper's bullet struck his spine and his companions dragged him to safety. His last words were "It was worth it." ( )

As near as I can tell, author Donovan Webster intended this book to be a sort of travelogue of his trek along the remnants of the Burma Road. That’s how it starts out; in the Prologue he’s trying to convince an Indian border guard officer to let him trek the few miles of the road in northwest India, despite not having a permit to travel in a restricted boarder area. He gets nowhere but manages a tone of offended incredulity. At the other end of the book, it’s clear from the acknowledgements that he did hike (or at least travel somehow) a good portion of the road (starting at the Chinese end), as he gives thanks to various hostelries and people in Myanmar for their hospitality. However, the rest of the work is a straightforward if journalistic history of the China-Burma-India theater in World War II.


Although suspicious of a WWII history written by a former senior editor at Outside magazine (expecting, perhaps, complaints that the Allies didn’t use ecologically sustainable methods to fight the Japanese) I was guiltily surprised. Although The Burma Road has some of the disadvantages of history as written by a journalist (overreliance on personal stories), it’s generally a pretty good history of the CBI – always the red-headed stepchild of WWII theaters of operation. The title probably came about because “Burma Road” is probably the only phrase the average American can connect with the campaign; as it happens very little text is devoted to it because although it was the focus of all the fighting in Burma by the time it was taken from the Japanese and the connecting Ledo Road was completed the war in China was no longer very important. Instead there are extensive accounts of the political infighting among General Joe Stilwell, Lord Mountbatten, and Generalissimo Chiang Kai-Shek; the irregular units that were initially the only way to take the war to the enemy in Burma (Kachin Levies, Chindits, and Merril’s Marauders); and the Japanese invasion of India in 1944 (even though it’s the “C” in CBI, fighting in China doesn’t get much coverage). Webster is very much a fan of Stilwell and Orde Wingate; complimentary to General William Slim; neutral to Lord Mountbatten, and doesn’t care very much for Claire Chennault or Chiang Kai-Shek. As the only American ground unit fighting in the theater (there were, of course, plenty of American pilots, air crew, supply units, and road engineers) the 5307th Composite Unit (Provisional), aka Galahad Force, aka Merril’s Marauders, gets a lot of coverage. (Webster cites an unnamed Marauder, pinned down on a riverbank by machinegun fire , suffering from malaria and jungle sores, and with the seat of his pants cut out to make things easier during dysentery attacks, shouting out to his comrades “Where the hell are the other 5306 Composite Units?”). There is also an obligatory mention of The Bridge on the River Kwai, and its ultimate destruction by a B-24 raid (one of the cases where the Norden bombsight worked to its full potential).


The maps are good, but there should be some more of them (although many of the actions in the Burmese jungle were so confused it’s probably impossible to map what was going on). Most of the first person accounts are from Americans or Japanese; I would have liked to see more from British, Burmese or Chinese participants. Overall a pretty good account of an underreported part of the war. ( )

Living in Asia focuses my reading interests and it was a recent visit to 'Vinegar Joe' Stilwell's former residence/office in Chungking, China two months ago, that was the impetus behind my wanting to put all the diverse bits of information I have acquired over the years of the CBI (the China-Burma-India Theatre in WWII) into a comprehensible whole. You know how it is--you've read books on Mao, on Chiang Kai-shek, on Chennault's Flying Tigers, on the Sino-Japanese War, and even Barbara Tuchman's superb work on Stilwell, but the pieces have never jelled.

This book does the trick, and I don't think it matters if you end up here, or start here, journalist/author Donovan Webster has done a superb job in weaving all those loose strands together into the rich tapestry of one of the most fascinating stories there is that came out of WWII. His characters are well drawn, the personal tales enrich the whole story in ways that simple facts wouldn't have cut it, and the book is one of the few I've found that tells a balanced story by including material taken from the diaries and biographies of the brave foot soldiers who fought this war regardless of uniform--Indian, American, Chinese, Burmese, Japanese. It's a page turner and if it leaves you wanting to know more, there are lots of excellent books on each of the major players in the story.

PS -- I've recommended this film in another review, but it's worth repeating. Anyone interested in this topic should do everything in their power to see the eloquent 1956 B&W Japanese anti-war movie directed by Kon Ishikawa that that tells the story of a young Japanese soldier who one day lays down his gun in Burma. It's called The Burmese Harp. ( )

http://pixxiefishbooks.blogspot.com/2...

I'd read Webster's shorter article on the Burma Road in National Geographic some time back and it had tweaked my interest. Having been over in that part of the world (Kanchanaburi and the River Kwai in 2004) also helped.

Overall, it was a good read, but not the one I'd expected. The back of the book was a bit misleading - it made it sound like the River Kwai events would play a much larger part in the book than the one chapter that they were actually given. This in itself is a little odd since the whole fight for control of the River Kwai was not, at least as far as I know, part of the fight for the Burma Road at all (though, I guess, you could argue that control fo the River Kwai was at least partially necessary in order to further the fight to clear the Japanese out of Burma and, eventually, Thailand).

Webster did his research and develops the leading players quite well. I'd say it's more a book for the military history buffs out there than for li'l ol' me, however. It did have some interesting background on China and Chiang Kai-Shek, which is an area of history I'd like to learn more about. ( )